The call to pray for the holy city creates an unbreakable bond between the destiny of Jerusalem and the people who hold it dear. This prayer goes far beyond a desire for physical walls and buildings; it captures a deep longing for national redemption, unity, and inner calm for the entire nation.
The primary approach among commentators is that this acts as a direct command and a heartfelt plea. People are instructed to pray to God and actively seek the peace of the city, hoping for its rebuilding and ultimate salvation [רד״ק, מצודת דוד, מאירי, ביאור שטיינזלץ]. This requested peace is not merely the absence of war. Rather, it represents the complete gathering of the exiled Israelites, because true safety from enemies is impossible until the people return home [רד״ק]. Furthermore, the focus of the prayer is specifically directed at the city itself, rather than just the Temple within it, highlighting Jerusalem's own unique holiness and inherent importance [אלשיך]. Offering a different perspective, some view this call not as a command, but as a reflection of the past. It describes the consistent habit of the ancient pilgrims who would constantly inquire about the city's well-being and offer prayers as they stood before it [אבן עזרא].
The focus then shifts to a direct, personal address to Jerusalem, offering the city a blessing or a prayer [רש״י, אלשיך, מצודת דוד, מאירי]. The hope is that those who love the city will live in quiet tranquility [ביאור שטיינזלץ, מצודת ציון]. These lovers of Jerusalem include the Israelites scattered in exile who mourn its ruin [רד״ק], the pilgrims and permanent residents who walk its streets [אבן עזרא], as well as the righteous individuals and sincere converts whose own standing is elevated when the city is rebuilt [תורה תמימה].
A profound cause-and-effect relationship connects the act of praying for the city with the reward of personal tranquility. One perspective suggests that Jerusalem does not actually need human prayers. Instead, the request for the city's peace is meant to benefit the people praying. By dedicating themselves to the city's well-being, the people themselves earn a life of peace [אלשיך]. Another approach draws a sharp distinction between external peace and internal tranquility. The external peace of Jerusalem depends entirely on the internal harmony of the people who love it. Because the city stands as the ultimate symbol of national unity, any conflict or division among the people makes peace in Jerusalem impossible. Only when the lovers of the city live together in love, unity, and inner peace will their harmony naturally bring about the long-awaited external peace for Jerusalem [מלבי״ם].