Following a decisive victory that restores the pride of the Israelites, the nation experiences a profound shift in perspective. The triumph serves as clear proof that God is with their new leader and that salvation has been delivered through his hands. As a result, the people unanimously accept Saul's kingship.
The primary approach among commentators notes that this newfound loyalty sparks a fierce reaction against those who had previously doubted the king. Earlier, certain individuals had spoken with contempt and mockery, questioning whether Saul was truly fit and worthy to rule. Now, fully convinced of his leadership, the people approach Samuel with a harsh demand. They insist that these former detractors be handed over and put to death. This severe request is rooted in the belief that anyone who previously disrespected Saul is now considered a rebel against the crown, and such rebellion carries a death sentence [מלבי״ם, ביאור שטיינזלץ].