The relationship between the king and his rising commander reaches a breaking point as continuous military victories fail to bring peace to the throne. Instead of celebrating the triumphs, the king falls into a deeper internal crisis, watching his young rival achieve extraordinary fortune in every endeavor.
This remarkable success is characterized by a shining favor in all of his actions [שטיינזלץ, אלשיך]. The level of triumph is so extreme and consistent that Saul realizes he is completely helpless to stop it or harm David in any way [מלבי״ם]. Looking deeper, this absolute success is not merely a stroke of luck but a direct result of profound righteousness [אלשיך]. Often, a person might succeed simply because God chooses to act with mercy. However, in this situation, the success is flawless because even the strict heavenly attribute of justice agrees with it. This righteousness adds strength in the heavenly court, rendering the young leader's rise completely unassailable.
Recognizing this divine backing and unstoppable momentum, Saul is struck with a deep, paralyzing terror. This is not a standard fear, but an overwhelming dread that surpasses his previous anxieties [מצודת ציון, מלבי״ם]. Two distinct motives fuel this intense terror. On a psychological level, the dread is rooted in the profound insecurity that had plagued Saul since the very day he was anointed king. He looks at his rival and sees the exact image of the successful, confident leader he had always desperately wanted to be [שטיינזלץ]. On a practical level, the sheer magnitude of this unstoppable success terrifies him with the very real threat that the kingship will soon be stripped away and taken by another [אלשיך].